
By Shawn Cole, President and co-founder of Cowen Partners Executive Search.
Most boards replace a chief executive by looking one level down.
Nike looked four years into retirement.
When Elliott Hill returned as CEO in October 2024 after spending more than three decades at the company and four years away from it, investors largely welcomed the move. Employees reportedly did too. Hill understood Nike’s culture, its athletes, its retailers and perhaps most importantly, its identity. Bringing back a lifelong insider fostered hope for a corporation striving to regain commercial momentum and strategic confidence.
Yet the appointment raised a more interesting governance question than most headlines acknowledged.
Why did one of the world’s most admired leadership factories need to search its past for its future?
A board reaching back to a recently retired executive is not succession planning working exactly as intended. It is, at the very least, a sign that the current leadership bench failed to produce an obvious choice.
The Successor Nike Appeared to Have
Nike was regarded as one of corporate America’s great leadership factories for decades. The company developed executives internally, moved them through increasingly demanding operating roles and built a culture where future leaders accumulated years of product, retail and international experience before reaching the executive suite.
By the late 2010s, Trevor Edwards seemed to embody that system. As President of the Nike Brand and the company’s second-most senior executive, he was widely viewed as the leading internal candidate to eventually succeed then-CEO Mark Parker.
Then came 2018.
In March of that year, Edwards resigned following an internal investigation into workplace conduct after complaints involving harassment, discrimination and inappropriate behaviour surfaced across parts of the organization. He retired from Nike later that summer.
His departure was only one part of a much broader leadership shake-up. Over the following months, approximately 11 senior executives left the company as Nike expanded its review of workplace culture. The investigation prompted one of the most significant executive turnovers in the company’s modern history, forcing leadership to confront problems that had accumulated beneath Nike’s celebrated culture.
The accountability itself was necessary. Boards cannot preserve succession plans by overlooking misconduct, nor should cultural reform ever be sacrificed to protect promising executives.
But accountability and succession are not the same exercise.
The governance consequence received far less attention than the cultural reckoning itself. The scandal hollowed out the layer of executives Nike would ordinarily have been developing into future CEO candidates.
The Executive Who Stayed
One detail often gets lost when the story is retold. Among the execs departing Nike in 2018 was not Elliott Hill. In fact, the same leadership announcement that confirmed Edwards’ departure also promoted Hill. He transitioned from President of Nike Geographies to the newly formed position of President of Consumer and Marketplace, putting him in command of one of the company’s major operational divisions.
His promotion expanded his responsibilities and moved him closer to the forefront of Nike’s strategic decision-making process. The move in isolation looked exactly like the kind of executive development boards want to see from a future chief executive.
With Edwards gone, Hill increasingly looked like Nike’s strongest remaining internal succession candidate. That did not guarantee he would become CEO. Large organizations rarely rely on a single presumed heir and effective boards prefer multiple credible options rather than one obvious favorite.
Even so, the leadership picture had clearly changed.
Nike had just experienced an unusually large turnover among senior executives. One of its most widely discussed CEO prospects had departed. The remaining bench inevitably became thinner than it had been only months earlier. That should have elevated succession planning from a routine governance process to an urgent board priority. But events rather took a different turn.
When Accountability & Succession Collide
When Mark Parker stepped down as CEO in 2020, Nike’s board faced one of its most important leadership decisions in decades. John Donahoe, a reputable technology and business leader whose resume includes eBay and ServiceNow but little experience in the footwear sector or consumer sports culture that had defined Nike for generations, was appointed by the board.
The decision reflected a clear strategic choice. Nike was expanding its direct-to-consumer objectives, spending extensively in digital commerce and seeking a chief executive with a track record of spearheading technology-driven transformation.
Donahoe’s hiring appeared at the time to be a purposeful shift in strategy rather than a rejection of Nike’s internal leadership pipeline. Only in hindsight does the decision take on greater significance. The same board came to the conclusion four years later that the executive it had previously dismissed was just the sort of leader the company needed.
Boards rarely get to revisit a succession decision so directly. Nike did.
That reversal does not indicate that Hill should have been appointed initially or that Donahoe was doomed to fail. Seldom is governance that easy. But it does pose an interesting question.
What does it say about the strength of the company’s remaining succession bench if the board ultimately gave its highest trust to a leader who had already retired?
The Donahoe Detour
John Donahoe did not arrive at Nike without credentials. Leading digitization at eBay and ServiceNow during a period when technology was metamorphosing almost every business, he had established himself as an effective operator. His mandate at Nike reflected the board’s interests. The company wanted to accelerate direct-to-consumer sales and modernize a business shaped by data and e-commerce rather than wholesale distribution alone.
Some of those objectives were achieved. Nike increased its digital sales and kept making big investments in its direct customer engagement. Yet the broader strategic bet proved more difficult to justify.
Competitors like Hoka, On, and New Balance earned major shelf space and consumer attention as Nike reduced its reliance on wholesale partners such as Foot Locker and Macy’s. Investors began to wonder if Nike had strayed too far from the product-led culture that had initially made it dominant as product innovation slowed and a number of iconic franchises lost momentum.
The company then launched a $2 billion cost-cutting initiative linked to workforce reductions and lowered its revenue forecast by the end of 2023. Another guidance cut in June 2024 triggered Nike’s steepest single-day share-price decline on record, wiping billions from its market value.
None of this proves Donahoe was the wrong executive in every respect.
It does suggest that the board’s 2020 succession decision ultimately failed to produce the leadership outcome it expected. And that is what makes Hill’s return so revealing. The deeper governance failure was not the appointment itself. It was the fact that the appointment looked more like recovery than succession.
The Hidden Cost of a Cultural Crisis
Most workplace scandals are evaluated through familiar measures.
- How much legal exposure did the company face?
- How much reputational damage was done?
- How badly was employee trust affected?
All of these are valid questions. But what happens to the leadership pipeline when the headlines pass is far less discussed.
Sacking CEOs may be necessary for misconduct, but boards cannot presume that accountability is the sole means of reinforcing organizational health. A cultural reckoning has the potential to wipe out years of accumulated expertise and weaken the generation of leaders expected to guide the organization forward. Those losses rarely appear on a balance sheet. Yet their consequences often emerge years later.
Hill’s return makes Nike’s 2018 leadership exodus look different in hindsight, because at the time it was rightly viewed as a necessary cultural reset. Six years later, it also appears to have marked the moment the company lost much of the leadership generation that would ordinarily have been competing for the CEO role. That is a succession problem as much as it is a cultural one.
Boards often spend years identifying a presumed heir.
Far fewer ask whether the generation behind that heir is equally strong.
The Governance Lesson
One presumed successor has never been a succession plan. It is simply optimism dressed as preparation.
Effective succession creates choice. It produces several credible executives who have been deliberately developed, tested across different parts of the business, and evaluated independently long before the board needs to make a decision. That discipline matters most immediately after a leadership crisis, precisely when the remaining bench appears thinnest.
The instinct is often to focus on repairing culture, restoring confidence, and replacing the executives who left. Boards must rebuild the next generation of leaders with the same urgency at the same time.
Succession planning succeeds only when tomorrow’s vacancies already have multiple credible answers.
Final Remarks
Elliott Hill may ultimately prove to be exactly the leader Nike needed.
If he restores growth, rebuilds product momentum, and reconnects the company with its competitive identity, his appointment will rightly be viewed as a successful decision.
But success would not erase the governance questions raised by his return.
Because a company only discovers what a cultural crisis really costs when it runs out of internal options and has to look backward.
Nike found a second chance in Elliott Hill.
The next board in the same position might not be so fortunate.
About Boardroom Pulse
Boardroom Pulse is the C-suite’s trusted source for forward-thinking, insightful coverage on corporate governance and the latest developments shaping today’s business world.
Our mission is simple yet ambitious: elevate governance standards and empower modern business leaders.
To achieve this, we deliver comprehensive, timely news, in-depth analysis, and thought leadership that spark dialogue, highlight best practices, and promote responsible leadership in boardrooms and executive suites nationwide.
That’s why more executive directors, board members, CEOs, and senior leaders turn to Boardroom Pulse—to navigate the complexities of the business landscape, strengthen the foundation for sustainable success, and refine governance strategies for a stronger future.




